Cottrell Title
Our Company & Team

Why Choose Us?
How Cottrell Title is Defining the Closing Experience
Timely Solutions
We provide proactive communication and offer timely solutions throughout the transaction.
Best Technology
Speedy Estimates
Create seller net sheets and calculate buyer’s closing costs in seconds.
Online Notarization
We offer remote online notarization.
Easy Escrow Deposits
Real Time Updates
Meet Our Team
Setting the Standard for Excellence in the Title Industry
Leadership Team

Justin Cottrell
- National Association of Consumer Bankruptcy Attorneys
- American Bar Association
- Bonita Springs Area Chamber of Commerce
- Bonita Springs Estero Realtors
- Naples Area Board of Realtors
- Young Professionals of Naples

Martín Nestares

Adam Bleggi
- Bonita Springs-Estero REALTORS®
- Naples Area Board of REALTORS®
- Legal Resources Committee Naples Area Board of REALTORS®
- Lee County Bar Association
- Collier County Bar Association
- Florida Bar, Real Property, Probate & Trust Law Section

Eric Nagel
- Affiliate member of NABOR (Naples Area Board of Realtors), BER (Bonita-Springs Estero-Realtors), WCR Naples & Bonita/Estero Chapters, and NAHREP (National Association of Hispanic Real Estate Professionals).
- NABOR "Humanitarian" and "Affiliate Rising Star" award recipient.
- NABOR Leadership Academy Graduate 2022.
- NABOR Community Involvement Committee Member.
- Florida State University Bachelor of Science (B.S.), Marketing.
- Lely High School Graduate and Naples resident since 1996.

Tina Razzano
Closing Team

Courtenay Porter

Chelsea Kiley

Jenna Wicks
A licensed Florida real estate agent since 2016, she has a well-rounded background and a true passion for managing and coordinating transactions, a strength that shines in her work. Already two months in, she has contributed to Cottrell and is positively impacting the clients we serve.
Originally from a small town in Upstate New York, Jenna moved to Southwest Florida in 2007 and spent 10 fulfilling years at home raising her two children, Nadia and John. She is deeply committed to building strong relationships with both clients and teammates and brings a driven, positive energy to everything she does.
We’re thrilled to have her as part of the Cottrell Title family!

James A. Schlimmer

Ginny Clark

Jaxon Portnoy

Julie Johnson
Delivering An Excellent Closing Experience
Who We Work With






Credentials & Partners
- Our staff has access to real estate and probate counsel at Grant Cottrell, PLLC.
- Bilingual closing team to serve the Hispanic Real Estate Community.
- The FIRPTA Group at Cottrell Tax & Accounting provides services to our non-resident clients requiring US ITINs, FIRPTA Withholding, and/or Tax Preparation services.
- RealProp Research is a company upon whom Cottrell Title can rely for efficient and accurate lien and estoppel searches.
- “Cottrell Cares” is our Community Involvement Initiative woven into the fabric of our culture of giving back while having fun along the way.
- Proud affiliate Members of NABOR (Naples Area Board of Realtors), BER (Bonita Springs-Estero Realtors), NAHREP (The National Association of Hispanic Real Estate Professionals), Women’s Council of Realtors (Naples On-the-Gulf), and the Mortgage Bankers Association of Southwest Florida.